Obama’s $447 Billion Jobs Plan Cuts Medicare, Taxes
Printer-friendly versionPDF version
a a
Type Size: Small
The Fiscal Times
September 9, 2011

Can a mix of tax breaks for individuals and businesses, infrastructure spending, and aid to state and local governments that is bound to be significantly smaller than the package proposed by the president Thursday night jolt the economy out of its doldrums?

As the details of his jobs plan emerged during the half-hour address to a joint session of Congress, it quickly became apparent that President Obama had listened to advisers from the left side of the political spectrum, who have been calling on the White House to issue a big and bold jobs plan to stimulate the economy. The president’s shrinking poll numbers – the latest Gallup poll shows just 41 percent of Americans approve his performance as president – undoubtedly had an impact on determining the size of the package.

In the days leading up to the nationally televised speech, the media had speculated that Obama would call for $300 billion in new spending and tax cuts. His $447 billion proposal, which included $253 billion in tax cuts and $194 billion in new spending, clearly exceeded those expectations.

But while even top Republicans on the Hill found some things to like in what the president called the American Jobs Act, many of the specific programs are likely to become bogged down in the usual wrangling on Capitol Hill. That will no doubt shrink the size of the stimulus that eventually passes.

“It seems the president was saying all or nothing, and if that doesn’t happen, he would seek to hold us accountable,” House Majority Leader Eric Cantor, R-Va., said on CNBC-TV. “That’s not the right approach.”

There’s also the issue of how to finance whatever package emerges from the negotiations. The president vowed to pay for every dime of the new tax cut-and-spending plan, and even pledged by a week from Monday to come up with a long-term deficit reduction plan that will exceed the $1.5 trillion goal of the Congressional Super Committee, which is slated to deliver its plan by Thanksgiving.

Where will the money come from? In what amounted to a finger-wag at his progressive supporters, he signaled that changes in Medicare, the senior citizen health care program, are likely to be part of the mix.

“If we don’t reform the system while protecting beneficiaries, it won’t be there when future retirees need it,” the president said. “We have to reform Medicare to strengthen it.”

Raising the specter of Medicare cuts will only make it more difficult to assemble the Congressional coalition needed to pass a significant economic stimulus package. Many Democrats are planning to use Republican support for privatizing Medicare as a major campaign issue in next year’s elections. Casting an “aye” vote for a stimulus “pay-for” that includes Medicare cuts will undoubtedly be used by Republicans next year to undercut their message.

However, the president is hoping politics-as-usual will give way to today’s economic reality, which is grim. Growth slowed to near stall speed in the first half of the year, and only 100,000 new jobs have been created in the last three months. The economy needs more than twice that many new jobs a month for the next four years to return to full employment.

As has been his forte throughout his political career, Obama seized the moment to deploy his considerable rhetorical skills in support of a Keynesian stimulus program. Only 24 hours earlier, the leading contender for the Republican nomination for president, Texas Gov. Rick Perry, had declared Keynesian economics dead and buried.

spent 25 years as a foreign correspondent, economics writer and investigative business reporter for the Chicago Tribune and other publications. He is the author of the 2004 book, The $800 Million Pill: The Truth Behind the Cost of New Drugs.