Corporate Tax Reform: The Math Gets Even Fuzzier
Printer-friendly versionPDF version
a a
Type Size: Small
The Fiscal Times
February 3, 2012

A corporate tax overhaul may be a pipe dream until at least 2013, but that isn’t stopping major corporate tax honchos from staking out their positions now on what the final plan should look like.  Their main message is that they are willing to avoid breaking the bank by relinquishing all of their corporate preferences in exchange for a tax rate of 25 percent or lower.

The top U.S. corporate tax rate is currently 35 percent—the highest of any country besides Japan, and that will change in April when Japan is scheduled to  cut its corporate rate by 2.5 percentage points.  When state taxes are added to the mix in the U.S., the corporate rate soars to 40 percent.  Yet few companies pay the full rate because of a convoluted system of tax write offs.

“We understand that in this era of growing budget deficits that base-broadeners need to be on the table,” said Anne Buettner, Senior Vice President of Tax for The Walt Disney Company.  “The Walt Disney Company supports the base-broadener concept along with a strong and meaningful reduction in the corporate tax rate …. Everything’s on the table.”
Buettner spoke on Wednesday at a conference in Washington sponsored by the RATE Coalition, a group advocating lower tax rates.
The chief tax officers for Macy’s Inc. and FedEx sounded a similar note, saying a revenue-neutral iteration of this formula would be a game-change that would enable them to  create jobs, offer higher pay and benefits to workers, and invest in the future of their businesses.  All three executives said their companies currently pay an effective tax rate of 34 percent or higher.
Despite the growing uncertainty over when – or if – Congress and the White House will take on fundamental tax reform, business executives throughout the country have signaled their interest in a tax reform recipe along the lines of what the three corporate executives outlined.
Last summer, the CEOs of Wal-Mart Stores and Kimberly-Clark urged the Senate Finance Committee to embrace a scheme that would lower rates while jettisoning tax preferences and write-offs.

Sen. Rob Portman, R-Ohio,  who served on the congressional Super Committee last fall, plans to unveil his own corporate tax reform plan in the coming weeks that will likely be along these lines.  Corporate tax reform is one of the few areas where lawmakers can “find bipartisan support and get something done” in the near future, he said Wednesday.
But there are many roadblocks:  For one, a 25 percent-or-lower tax rate can’t be attained by simply eliminating all the corporate tax breaks and subsidies from the code.