Scrolling through a list of the biggest first-day “pops” for Internet and technology IPOs is like entering a time machine set for the go-go days of the dotcom boom.
Many of the names may still be familiar, even if they’re no longer around: Ask Jeeves (with a 364 percent pop), Sycamore Networks (386 percent) and Theglobe.com (606 percent) flared spectacularly and then flamed out, quickly or over time. VA Software tops the historic list with a one-day jump of nearly 700 percent, according to Dealogic. Only a few of the stocks – Priceline.com, Akamai Technologies – have established themselves as something significantly more than one-day wonders.
For all the frenzy surrounding its first day of trading, Twitter (TWTR) doesn’t even come close to making the list. In the context of dotcom mania, Twitter’s first-day gain almost seems reasonable: The social messaging service’s stock finished its first day of public trading at $44.90 a share, up 73 percent from its $26 IPO price. But then, those ‘90s Internet IPOs were far smaller than Twitter’s, which raised as much as $2.1 billion. Among larger U.S. stock offerings – those that raised $500 million or more – Twitter’s pop ranks as the sixth biggest, according to Dealogic data cited by The Wall Street Journal.
Twitter’s first-day gain was also far higher than the average 17 percent “pop” for new U.S. stock listings this year and better than nearly all of the opening performances posted by the largest tech and Internet IPOs.
|Top 20 Tech IPOs|
|Issuer||Total Value $ including Non-Deal (m)||Exchange||Pricing Date||% Change Price Offer/1 Day|
|Facebook Inc.||16,007||Nasdaq||May 12, 2012||0.6|
|Infineon Technologies AG||5,856||Frankfurt General, NYSE||Mar. 12, 2000||100.4|
|Agere Systems Inc||4,140||NYSE||Mar. 27, 2001||0.3|
|Tycom LTD||2,250||NYSE||Jul. 26, 2000||12.5|
|Agilent||2,160||NYSE||Nov. 17, 1999||48.3|
|Verisk Analytics Inc.||2,156||Nasdaq||Oct. 6, 2009||23.7|
|1,916||Nasdaq||Aug. 18, 2004||18.0|
|Genuity Inc.||1,913||Nasdaq||Jun. 27, 2000||-14.5|
|Semicondictor Manufacturing International||1,803||NYSE||Mar. 12, 2004||-11.4|
|Freescale Semiconductor Inc||1,690||NYSE||Jul. 16, 2004||7.9|
|EPCOS AG||1,633||Frankfurt General, NYSE||Oct. 14, 1999||8.1|
|Yandex NV||1,435||Nasdaq||May 23, 2011||55.4|
|Infonet Services Corp||1,238||NYSE||Dec. 15, 1999||27.1|
|Alcatel Optronics SA||1,205||Nasdaq, Paris||Oct. 19, 2000||-0.6|
|VMWare Inc.||1,101||NYSE||Aug. 13, 2007||75.9|
|LG Philips LCD Co. LTD||1,059||Korea, NYSE||Jul. 15, 2004||-6.3|
|KPNQwest BV||1,054||Amsterdam, Nasdaq||Nov. 9, 1999||51.5|
|Shanda Games Ltd.||1,044||Nasdaq||Sep. 24, 2009||-14.0|
|Giant Interactive Group Inc.||1,020||NYSE||Oct. 31, 2007||17.6|
|NavTeq Corp||1,012||NYSE||Aug. 5, 2004||15.0|
Twitter’s surge means that investors who bought into the initial offering are sitting pretty even as those who bought shares at the opening price of $45.10 lost a bit of money. The pop prompted analyst Brian Wieser of Pivotal Research Group to downgrade the stock to “sell” shortly after it started trading. The shares, he wrote, would be fairly valued in the high $20 to low $30 range. “However,” he added, “with a price that pushes into the high 30s and beyond, Twitter is simply too expensive.”
The first-day jump also means that, for all the warnings about Twitter's lofty initial valuation and for all the reminders that the social messaging service has yet to post a profit, the company likely left a sizable chunk of change – more than $1 billion – on the table.
Still, the company’s IPO will go down as a successful one, and a sharp contrast to the problem-plagued debut of Facebook’s stock last year. Now Twitter just has to prove that it can reward investors’ enthusiasm.
Top Reads from The Fiscal Times: