The Woman Who Brought Down a Massive Tax Fraud Ring
Policy + Politics

The Woman Who Brought Down a Massive Tax Fraud Ring


Two years ago, a branch manager at Widget Financial, a federal credit union in Erie, Pennsylvania, began to get suspicious. He had been processing several account opening requests and thought it unusual that they had all come from distant New York City. At around the same time, a Widget vice president got a strange phone call from a New Yorker complaining that he had never opened an account with Widget, yet was receiving mail from the credit union.

The coincidental occurrence of two red flags was enough to catch the attention of Widget CEO Gail Cook, who ordered her information technology department to pull the details of every account from New York, Connecticut and Rhode Island that had been opened in the previous two years.

Related: Little Credit Union Uncovers Massive Tax Fraud

Cook had no idea that she had just taken the first steps in uncovering a massive tax fraud scheme that involved thousands of stolen identities, fake tax returns, and millions of dollars drained from the U.S. Treasury.

Cook said in an interview that as soon as the details from eight different accounts were put side-by-side, she and her employees began to see problems. “There was a lot of cut-and-paste type information,” she said. There were driver’s licenses with the same person’s photo and different names, and multiple names listing the same address.

The next step was to examine account activity, and on some of the accounts, Cook said, there was nothing other than run-of-the-mill transaction activity. But others were different, with activity almost exclusively limited to money order purchases and payments to and from pre-paid credit card accounts.

And direct deposits from the Internal Revenue Service.

Related: IRS Gives Tax-Dodging Workers $3M in Bonuses

Cook immediately called the local FBI field office, and an agent was in the credit union within a day, returning not long afterward with representatives of the IRS Criminal Investigations Division.

“This looks like a pretty big deal,” the agent said at one point, but until last week Cook and her employees had no idea how big.

Cook had heard nothing further about the case until her phone rang and she found herself speaking to the local FBI agent who had first visited her office.

“He said, ‘I just want to thank you. You have no idea what you all did,” Cook remembers.

It turned out that Widget Financial had uncovered a massive tax fraud scheme. Five men from New York, Rhode Island, and Tennessee had, since at least 2005, been using stolen identities to fill out thousands of fake tax returns demanding refunds from the IRS.

According to David J. Hickton, U.S. Attorney for the Western District of Pennsylvania, the men had operated a “massive stolen identity ring” that filed claims for some $21 million in refunds, and were paid at least $10 million.

Related: 10 Signs the IRS Might Audit You

Ironically, one of the institutions where the fraud ring opened a fake account was the Treasury Department Federal Credit Union in Washington, DC, which serves, among others, employees of the IRS. Other institutions identified in the indictment include PNC Bank, Air Force Academy Credit Union, Pennsylvania State Employees Credit Union, and others.

Despite the much larger size of some of the other institutions they targeted, it was little Widget Financial that tripped up the members of the fraud ring.

Cook said that to her and her employees, it was just part of the job. “Being vigilant and thorough is part of the DNA of this credit union and we take these matters very seriously,” she said.

Top Reads from The Fiscal Times