Enough Already with Stimulus Spending

Enough Already with Stimulus Spending

Printer-friendly version
a a
Type Size: Small

When it comes to government spending, “stimulus” apparently means never having to say “enough.”

You may not realize it to listen to, say, Paul Krugman,  but Congress has already passed three separate stimulus bills, at a total cost of roughly $1 trillion.  

The first of these came back in February 2008 under the Bush administration: a $152 billion measure, featuring a $600 tax rebate, several incentives for businesses, and loan guarantees for the housing industry   At the time the economic downturn was just beginning and unemployment was 4.9 percent. 

Then, as the recession picked up steam in September 2008, Congress passed the $61 billion “Job Creation and Unemployment Relief Act of 2008.”  This bill pumped money into federal “infrastructure projects” and extended unemployment insurance.  One month later, unemployment reached 6.5 percent.

And of course, last year President Obama pushed through the giant $787 billion stimulus bill that was the hallmark of his first year in office.  When the bill passed, the unemployment rate was 8.1 percent.  

Today, unemployment is 9.5 percent and Congress is again debating a stimulus bill, this time a $34 billion measure in the Senate (The House-passed version cost $60 billion) to provide grants for state and local governments, extend unemployment benefits again, and provide for more targeted business tax breaks. 

All of this does not even include TARP I or II, or last year’s budget which hiked spending for all sorts of “job creating” programs. 

Clearly, all this government spending hasn’t done much to reduce unemployment or spur economic growth.  But it has spurred the growth of government.  Federal government spending last year topped 24.7% of gross domestic product, the highest peacetime percentage in history. That compares to a historical average of roughly 21%.  Throw in state and local spending, and government at all levels consumes more than 36 percent of everything that the U.S. economy produces. 

Perhaps that has something to do with the reason why our economy is not growing or producing jobs.    Or perhaps businesses are anticipating the tax increases to come next year when the Bush tax cuts expire.  Some may even be looking a bit further ahead to the mandates, taxes, and regulations that will eventually be imposed as a result of the recently enacted health care legislation.  The new taxes from that bill alone will total more than $669 billion, many penalizing investment income, and while most won’t hit for a couple years, many businesses are already considering the trade-offs.  And, of course, higher energy taxes also remain on the table.